Does your luminaire warranty cover all eventualities?

March 5, 2018



Welcome to this month’s blog – In this article, we look at warranties- their potential pitfalls and how to avoid them.


Warranties for luminaire products should at first glance, should be a simple issue – However, many warranties do not cover the product for all eventualities which may occur onsite, and some can be simply misleading!


A warrant may be conditional – and may not include coverage for an issue that can occur due to the nature of the site or application.


Q- Does the warranty include lumen maintenance?


Most warranties should include lumen maintenance – but be warned! Some warranties only cover total product failure.


This means the warranty does not cover underperformance -where the products delivered light levels have dropped below usable requirements - but the unit is still dimly working.


In such cases- unsafe lighting levels can result onsite [potentially leading to accidents and insurance claims] and the purchaser is left with the new product+ labor cost – along with a damaged reputation and a loss of future work. 


Some manufacturers will state the warranty is not a guarantee of light level performance, and will simply walk away.


Some suppliers may alter the manufacturer’s original warranty conditions- reducing the warranty period and changing the conditions [such as removing a guarantee of lumen maintenance – or reducing the drivers warranty period]. 


Always check the conditions of the warranty – Make sure it includes/guarantees the lumen maintenance.   


Warning – some warranties have provisions on running time – which are misleading!


 Some warranties state a guarantee of 5 years – providing the unit is only powered up for 20,000Hrs!

 In such cases – the manufacturer has a get-out clause- also bear in mind that life span will vary with onsite conditions.


There may also be clauses, restricting the number of on/off switch cycles – so a luminaire operated by occupancy sensors may fail early – leaving the customer without warranty cover!


Another point to consider is – will the supplier still be around after 50,000-Hrs, if the supplier has a long market history it may be the case- but there are plenty of fly-by night traders out there.




We saw an LED streetlight advertised on a well-known internet sales site, with the following worded warranty -


Warranty = 10 years /10,000Hrs.


There is no mention of a guarantee of long lasting light level performance!


The warranty is unclear – and can be interpreted as follows:


The warranty only covers 10,000Hrs operation time [when used over a 10-year period]


However – supposing the number of switch-start operations is exceeded in the first 5,000 hrs. [If the unit was switched from a sensor] causing the unit to fail?


What will the seller decide to do?


It is hard to see how the E bay seller can state they will honor the warranty– as there was no point of contact for the supplier!


Warranties may include additional conditions that may override other clauses-


Warranties can be voided if the products recommended Ta ratings have been exceeded – if a product has a maximum Ta of 45C and the site’s ambient temperature is 50C, the product may have a reduced light output – or fail.


When selecting a lighting product – always check the product can handle the maximum expected onsite temperature conditions - on the hottest day of the year, if the site temperatures are higher than expected, it could lead to onsite failures – with no refund from the supplier.


One potential pitfall occurs, when onsite staff [who are not lighting technicians] are asked to estimate the max, onsite temperature for the supplier, who will then check the products Ta rating – bear in mind that temperatures at ceiling height [or fixed into cavities] can be much higher than expected [the staff cannot be expected to know the ceiling height temperatures -during the hottest day of the year]


Often such data is done over the phone – so there is no record of who said what, at the time of install.

We recommend using Emails for such information requests – and to use a lighting technical to survey the site [taking max, site temperatures into consideration] the lighting technical can then apply a degree of headroom, when selecting the products – to play safe. 


In such cases -where the onsite staff have guessed the max, temperature incorrectly, a debate as to who is responsible for product failure, will place the responsibility onto the supplier or installer– who will have to pay replacement costs+ labor costs!


Also bear in mind - what temperatures may occur on the hottest day of the year [sometimes there is no data available] so a survey conducted in winter may rely on hearsay.     


Other factors come into play – such as changes in site conditions or routines throughout the year – as well as climate change [global warming].


We have seen some warranties claim 100,000Hrs product lifespans


As far as we know -at the moment, no one has run a high powered LED for 100,000Hrs at onsite conditions to show this is the possible onsite.


These warranties are based on LED lifespan predictions.


Many LEDs have a Max, LM80 prediction time of 42,0000Hrs and rising -at present. But one company has recently claimed 100,000 Hrs LED lifespan [based on an LM80 predictions]


This claim may be correct - for that particular LED, used at a particular drive current/temperature [we have not seen the data used for the prediction] However, there are many issues to consider regarding this statement.


1. The LED used for the 100,000Hr prediction does not represent all LEDs on the market- an assumption may be made that all LEDs predicted to perform for 50,000Hrs can actually perform to 100,000Hrs. The running temperatures and drive current, and type of start-up wave form of the completed products – will affect each units LEDs differently.


Reliability is heavily linked to good luminaire design – onsite conditions also affect the product life span.


2. Competitors may copy this claim, on the basis that they are using the same make/model of LED – but the LED could be running at a higher temperature and current –when inside the competitor’s product. This raises concern that the market will be flooded with false claims – making it hard to discern, which product has such abilities.


Bear in mind- there is a difference between LED reliability and product reliability, a product is only as good as its weakest link! 


There are many variables involved in product reliability such as:


1. on/off switch cycle limits – or surge/spike handling v degree of repetition/level/ of voltage spikes onsite]


2. The lifespan of the heatsink paste [used to shift heat from the LED board to the heatsink]


3. If the luminaire is working outside [in the rain] - will the sealing gaskets last for 100,000hrs?


4. If metal corrosion occurs- the mountings and seals may be compromised.


5. Repetitive thermal expansion/contraction effects – may eventually create a gap between the LED board and the heatsink [leading to overheating]


6. Long term exposure to gases [such as Sulphur dioxide from cars- chlorine from swimming pools – which can damage LEDs – it may be hard to predict, what gas levels occur on a street ,or site over 11 years – or what level of gas exposure would occur over that period.  


7. Long term dust build up – dust can be coating the heatsink /driver – reducing the product lifespan.


8. The driver may not be rated to last for 100,000hrs. We note some drivers can be ran at a reduced wattage and run cooler – some Meanwell drivers are capable of running for 100,000Hrs [if running at lower temperatures and kept clean] However-this would mean running a 200W driver at a lower wattage [this increases product cost]


9. If the paint work will still be UV resistant – and not peeled off [street lights with peeling paint and rust may look unsightly] also consider – if the paint has peeled, UV rays from sunlight may no longer be reflected off during hot sunny days, this could cook the internal capacitors – leading to a reduced lifespan [even when not powered up] 


Peeled off paint could also expose micro-pitted metal work on the heatsinks– with could fill with dirt/dust [leading to overheating]


We believe a recognized test standard should be made [dealing with these issues and more] to officially confirm a luminary’s 100,000Hrs product lifespan – for various applications [but including long-term material tests]    



Product cost?


We would expect a 100,000hr performance luminaire would need to have extensive component testing, to ensure all the components will last this long, we also believe the Ta rating would be vitally important [there may have Ta limits lower than other products]


As components such as gaskets/paint/capacitors/connectors/ solder connections /heatsink paste would have to all last for 100,000Hrs – we would expect the cost of the unit to be higher than usual.

Another concern is - would the product life span test, include simulating the actual conditions the luminaire will be exposed to on your particular site? 


Q-If unforeseen failures do occur – will the supplier cover the labor costs as well as replacing the products.


Future proofing?


One point to consider is the fact that every year LED are getting more efficient- after 50,000Hrs, the next generation of products could provide even greater energy savings.


Q- Which is preferred- a 100,000hr product running at 130 lumen per watt- or a 130 lumen per watt /50,000-Hr product eventually being replaced by a 200/250 lumen per watt product for the next 50,000Hrs [possibly with additional intelligent energy saving features]?    


Also bear in mind – a new high-tech material has been discovered – called Graphene. When graphene technology is used to enhance LEDs /capacitors – we may see a great leap forward, in terms of higher Ta ratings/energy efficiency/LED lifespan/robustness.


Electrolytic capacitors, are often a weak link in terms of temperature handling – carbon based super capacitors are now arriving, with increased capacity/smaller size/ higher temperature ratings – the shape and design/handling abilities/efficiency of luminaires will change!


A graphene technology filament light emitter has also been patented –with a potential for very high lifespan and temperature handling- this could provide more options in addition to LEDs.


Imagine finding out after 50,000hrs that the new products work far more efficiently- making it worth your while to change the 100,000Hr lifespan unit’s half way through their service life – having paid extra for the 100,000hrs product and its extended warranty?


Future energy costs v future developments?


100,000Hrs constant running time equates to 11.4 years- by that time the cost of electricity may have risen dramatically – and, new units could provide greater energy savings – it is worth considering the possible economics.


Not so long ago, we saw a jump from 90 lumens per watt to 130 lumens per watt – this trend continues.


The maximum theoretical lumen per watt limit [by the laws of physics] is 683Lpw! It is not hard to imagine that 200 lumens per watt performance, will arrive on the market in 5 years’ time – or even greater, with the introduction of new graphene technologies [without considering the possibility of new types of technology being invented]


We do not predict a fall in electricity costs over 11 years– the current data suggest the opposite will occur.


Energy managers must consider the future effects of economic changes v potential technological improvements – when thinking ahead over such a long term period, bearing in mind - the last 11 years have seen a profound improvement in product efficiency- which will continue.


Thank you for reading this blog.

Please reload

Featured Posts

Regarding 100,000hrs Lumen maintenance claims for LED lighting

December 4, 2018

Please reload

Recent Posts

February 6, 2017

Please reload

Please reload

Search By Tags
Follow Us
  • Facebook Basic Square
  • Twitter Basic Square
  • Google+ Social Icon

© 2017 by MG Lites Energy Saving Solutions Limited